Matthew Leslie

Can you follow this border without getting dizzy?
Aside from somehow managing to not come up with a majority of Asian Citizen Aged Voter Population in its District 1, containing the largely Korean-American Amerige Heights, one of the most remarkable things about the bar owners’ Map 8 (and it’s now updated version 8A, below) is the quirky little isthmus of territory that juts westward from its District 3, on the East side, into its District 2, to the West. Take a look at the map above.
The entire map is so gerrymandered to achieve the pointless goal of connecting all districts to Downtown Fullerton that one might easily miss the finer points of its corrupt design. One of these mildly subtle features is the inclusion of about half of a neighborhood just north of Rolling Hills Drive into the Cal State Fullerton eastern District 3. Why is there a curved line here, instead of a straight line that follows St. College Blvd. to the city’s border?

Like Fullerton’s own Berlin Wall, needlessly dividing a neighborhood.
With so many other eccentric boundaries lines in place in Map # 8A, one more might not seem out of place, unless one considers that Councilmember Greg Sebourn lives just above Rolling Hills Dr., just east of the line that cleaves his neighborhood in two. This curious residential division places his house in a different district than that of his fellow council member, Doug Chaffee, against whom he will have to run for city council once again in 2018, should they both decide to seek new terms in office. During the May 17 meeting of the Fullerton City Council, Mr. Chaffee even made light of the possibility that he and Mr. Sebourn might end up in the same elections district, joking that the two of them could just endorse one another. (Of course, it is entirely inappropriate, to say the least, for members of the city council to even bring up the subject of their own residences while considering which map to adopt for district elections, but more about that subject later…)
Map # 8A won’t have either of them worrying, as It provides a cozy little niche that keeps Mr. Sebourn not only away from Mr. Chaffee’s district, but also separates him from anyone else in the vast and wealthy Golden Hills/Raymond Hills region, District 2 in this map, that has spawned so many other past and current members of the Fullerton City Council. This egregious example of gerrymandering is just one reason to vote against Map # 8A, which is being championed almost exclusively by bar owners, whose map would rob the residents of the greater downtown area of a collective voice by dividing their district five ways. Mr. Sebourn should stand up for residents of the city he represents, and not be tempted by the geographic morsel offered up for his support of what is easily the worst map up for consideration on June 7.
Like this:
Like Loading...
Related
I wish I could make the next council meeting. How much more ludicrous can this become? I know! I want to see the lines zigzagged so that all senior citizens are represented by all. Let’s give that to all the churches on Acacia and elsewhere, too. smh
LikeLike
I agree with the general concern about gerrymandering district to protect existing incumbents, but I would argue that is more of a reason to oppose district elections in general, because that’s pretty much where every city that adopts district elections is headed, either in this cycle or when the next map is created in 2021. I understand that this is pretty much being forced on us, I’m just arguing Jaramjillo and her legal team are as much of a villain here as the downtown bar owners.
As for the actual beneficiary, I’m not sure whether it necessarily helps Sebourn. It does keep him out of “Chaffee’s” district but you’d need to look at the precinct by precinct election returns (as opposed to the Citywide totals) to see if Chaffee is stronger in the neighborhoods that the two would potentially be competing in. Also, under this map everything west of Sebourn would now be out of his district which means he would lose a good chunk of his neighbors and the people who helped him get elected in the first place.
LikeLike
Perhaps it is a big F U from the Bar Owners/Establishment Republicans who tried to push him out in 2014. Good reason for him to oppose it.
LikeLike